
DGV is particularly interested in consumer tech marketplaces and identifying global opportunities based on successful models from other regions. In this episode, Scott Kelly sits down with their founder, Justin Caldbeck, whose wealth of experience working with major venture capital firms allows him to provide the right support to high-net-worth individuals. He talks about providing not only capital but also recruitment guidance, strategic advice, and mentorship to their portfolio companies. Justin also shares valuable insights about using AI tools and monolithic funds, especially right now when the venture is in a bit of a transition mode.
—
Watch the episode here
Listen to the podcast here
Exploring Consumer Tech Marketplaces With Justin Caldbeck Of DGV
Scott, you’ve got Justin Caldbeck on DGV, and he’s got a big broad international approach. He’s got investors and family offices, and venture partners that he’s working with from all over.
He’s been with some of the largest firms in the history of venture capital, and because of that, he brings that large VC connection and access to deal flow and access to capital. Now with this current firm, he can use all those resources, but be a little more personal one-on-one with the interaction with both his LPs and both the entrepreneurs he invests in.
I think it’s really great for founders and other investors to be exposed to someone who’s got experience with companies and investments in like LinkedIn, Stitch Fix, Grubhub, and Snapchat. You’re not talking about. Everyone seems to have the same list of what I’m going to call B investments, which are slightly below that, but these are giant ones. McKinsey, Bain Capital. The Consumer Tech Fund and its current seed fund have deep industry expertise here.
He has been, like you said, involved in some of the largest, most successful companies in the history of venture. He has that experience, as I mentioned before. I think when you make an investment with someone with his background, you get some real expertise because a lot of times, know, entrepreneurs, they breathe a sigh of relief when they get to their seed or series A fund, but what happens next? You need to have someone who can quarterback the subsequent rounds. I think that’s really what he brings to the table.
I was thinking about this, and I think that often, as a founder, we ask for strategic investors. That’s what we’re really out there looking for. Often, we don’t always understand what that means, but that means that he can tap into these great companies and recruit some people for you, like that’s a really big deal. You’ve got a much more collaborative investment partner.
You just imagine if your investor has the founder of LinkedIn on speed up. The reality is those are the relationships he has because of the experience he’s developed over time.
He’s going to tell us a little bit about DGV. He’s really quiet about it. I love that there’s no website on the blog for this episode. He didn’t want to share it, which I think is great. He did give us a connection point to his LinkedIn. DGV is particularly interested in consumer tech marketplaces and identifying global opportunities based on successful models from other regions. They provide not only capital, recruitment support, strategic advice, and mentorship to all of their portfolio companies. That’s a really unique thing. Let’s hear from Justin Caldbeck, all about DGV and his mission in the emerging managers world.
From his beginnings at McKinsey and Bain Capital Ventures to launching his own consumer tech fund and his current seed fund, DGV, Justin brings deep industry expertise, a global perspective, and a focus on delivering exceptional returns. He’s not just about capital; Justin is also passionate about helping entrepreneurs succeed by providing recruitment support, strategic advice, and a collaborative approach to venture investing. Follow Justin Caldbeck on Social: LinkedIn About DGV DGV is Justin Caldbeck’s current seed fund, focusing on participating in early-stage investments rather than leading them. DGV has a geographically agnostic strategy, investing both in the US and internationally, with a portfolio spanning across Europe, South America, Africa, and Southeast Asia. The fund has shown strong performance compared to its vintage, aiming to deliver significant returns to its LPs. DGV is particularly interested in consumer tech, marketplaces, and identifying global opportunities based on successful models from other regions. The fund provides not only capital but also recruitment support, strategic advice, and mentorship to its portfolio companies. Welcome everybody. I’m honored to welcome an old friend of mine, Justin Caldbeck. Justin, welcome to the show. Thank you, Scott. Thanks so much for having me. I’m excited to be here. Justin, what we’re you trying to do? We’re going to get to what you’re doing now in the VC investing space. I’d love to get a little background about what you did prior to your current fund, and currently what you’re doing now professionally and personally, and talk a little about your background. I’ll give you my full background. Born and raised, and grew up in a little town, Shulmer, Vermont, went down to Duke for undergrad, and played basketball there. I started my career professionally at McKinsey right out of Duke. That’s really where I first fell in love with technology. I had had no exposure to it before, but started to serve tech clients and realized I love that industry. I didn’t like consulting as much. I went up to Harvard for business school, technically came back to McKinsey for a year and a day to pay off my loans. I started investing. I got recruited to Bain Capital Ventures. I was an analyst initially there. Worked up to be a partner there initially in Boston. I actually moved out alone in 2008 to open up their West Coast office. I worked on the early investment in LinkedIn there. I ended up hatching a company. I had a thesis around productizing SEO at the time, brought two founders together, and funded it. It’s called Bloomreach. It’s now about a 2 1/2 billion dollar company. I got recruited over by Lightspeed to go co-lead their consumer tech groups. Prior to my joining, extraordinary firm, lots of success on the enterprise and infrastructure level, but not a lot of success on the consumer side. When I joined, I ended up leading the early investments in Stitch Fix, sat on the board, took it public, ended up leading the early investment in Grubhub, sat on the board, and it went public. TaskRabbit, I was number two on the seed investments there at Snapchat and a firm. I was also doing a lot of personal investing in cases where I couldn’t get light speed to go ahead and get involved. I ended up doing personal investments in Opendoor, Uber, SpaceX, Collective Health, and a number of other companies. I left in fourteen to go start a fund for all-around consumer tech. A partner and I raised about $300 million for that. That fund has done very well, returns-wise. Excited about where that’ll end up from a returns perspective, but I left in seventeen. I took a couple of years off with the family, and I realized like, “This is what I love to do.” It’s what I love to do. I stand up a family office for my wife. We started making a bunch of personal investments. First investor in Whatnot, which is now about a $5 billion live stream shopping company. First investor in Eightfold AI, which is a couple of billion-dollar AI HR platform company. In early 2021, I was approached by a multifamily office in Europe. They knew about my background and asked me if I would be open to taking an anchor check from them and doing a seed fund. I got to know them over about six months and got really excited about it. Started a seed fund. I called it DGV, which was just a placeholder name. D was short for the firm’s name. I have been doing that since 2021. That’s an amazing track record. I think the only thing I’m more excited about in your investments is the great artwork you have behind you from your kids. Congratulations on that, too. Talk a little bit more about the fun thesis. Obviously, you’ve had a prolific background in some of the legendary companies. Talk about what you’re doing now specifically. What stage, check size, and where do you play in the ecosystem? I love it. My entire career has been at Bain Capital, at Lightspeed, and at Binary. My entire career has been leading series A investments, sometimes seed investments, but leading. As you know, the bar to lead is a much higher bar than to participate. I was going head-to-head with Sequoia or General Catalyst or when I was at Binary Lightspeed or other tier one firms. I loved it, but the bar is higher. You’re really trying to earn the right to be their sole board member for that round in a lot of cases. Super proud of the work I did there. At this firm, I’ve taken a different approach, which is in two ways. One, we’re not leading. We’re just participating. We work with other groups. We’re very collaborative with a number of other funds. I’m personally an LP in about almost twenty funds. Good network of funds that we work closely with. Secondly, I’ve taken a more geographically agnostic stance. Just over 50% of our investments are here in the US, but we have some really exciting companies internationally as well. We’ve got some great companies in Europe, in South America, and in Africa. We’re in the leading food delivery company in Africa. If you look in Southeast Asia, we’re in an honest bank, which is the new bank of Southeast Asia, growing very quickly, and a number of other great companies are there. We’ve got some investments in China. We’ve got a fantastic portfolio of companies, and it’s been working. We’re a 2021 vintage, Scott. If you look at the median marks for 2021 vintage funds, it’s basically flat to 1.0. We’re at almost 1.8 X. We have already distributed some capital. We’ve got DPI and I think it’s actually under mark in the sense that we’re still actually deploying from the fund. We’ve been slower to deploy, but I feel really good about that. Again, our check sizes are, we’ll go as small as 100K up to three-quarters of a million or a million. We will look anywhere, which has been helped by a scout network we’ve developed. That’s awesome. I’m glad you brought that up in terms of returns and such, because the whole Genesis of putting together this podcast was an article that I saw at the end of last year, there were eighteen venture capital funds were getting roughly 78% of all the LP capital invested. There were 3,200 venture capital funds that they had last year, and 1800 of them were fund one. I’m glad you brought that up. In this environment where you’ve got these monolithic funds, several you’ve been a part of, why your fund versus them and why right now? I’m saying it’s a little bit tongue in cheek, but it’s like, “Do you care about returns or do you care about the brand of the firm?” When I’m an LP in funds, I have no interest in investing in these massive monolithic funds with the exception of maybe 2 or 3. I think Founders Fund is a world-class fund still. I think Sequoia is a world-class fund still. I think Benchmark is a world-class fund still. In those cases, too, some cases haven’t been optimized for how much capital they’ve raised. They continue to be, I just think, world-class from a returns perspective. It’s not true for most of the big funds. I’ve been a part of those funds. I have seen the evolution of funds from we care first and foremost about optimizing returns to we care first and foremost around capital raising. Look, I get it. I totally understand the motivations behind wanting to raise lots of capital and generating massive fees. Look, for many, this is true for all types of people, but when you’ve made a lot of money, your motivations for grinding for the next deal can decrease. I’ve seen that too among my partners. Guys are spending half the summer in Hawaii and other things. I get why a lot of LPs, particularly institutional LPs, choose to invest in those funds. You don’t get fired if you’re sitting at the North Carolina endowment, you don’t get fired for putting money in those groups. The reality is that those groups are index funds. They don’t have the alpha that I believe you should be able to generate in early-stage venture capital. That’s where my focus is. When I was at my last fund, we capped our fundraising well south of where we could have raised it because we didn’t believe in the idea of just optimizing for fundraising. That’s, I think, the core trade-off you make between betting on an early fund 1, fund 2, maybe fund 3, where there’s still a lot of that grit and drive, etc., but behind a manager that has proven themselves, him or herself as an angel in other ways versus investing in fund ten, multi-billion dollar index fund. That’s the reason why we set this up, because the reality is that at the end of the day, we’re finding a lot of folks want to get into venture, high net worth individuals, not just the major institutions. The RIAs and advisors who are independent who want to get better than an ETF return for a portion of their clients before or for their overall portfolio. I appreciate your thesis of going for a return versus fundraising. Let’s talk about a little bit industry. You talked obviously geographically that you’re investing in the United States and Africa, and other parts of the world. What industries are you looking at now? Obviously, AI is the dot-com of this era, but what are you looking at in terms of industry, and where do you think the next things are going to be? Look, I spent a lot of time in consumer tech. That has been my career for the last multiple decades. Early in Grubhub food delivery, early in Stitch Fix, Uber, Opendoor, LinkedIn, more recently, whatnot. For many years, I’ve been getting the question, “Aren’t we done with consumer. Is there anything else?” I just find it so laughable because in every industry, there’s so much room for continued improvement and optimization. I look at Whatnot. Whatnot is a company, for those of your readers that aren’t familiar, they do live stream shopping. What does that mean? Historically, if I wanted to go sell a product, if I wanted to sell this drink or a sports card on eBay, I would take a picture of it, I would write a description, and I would either put a buy it now price or I’d start an auction. That would be what I’d do. In China, you’ve seen Taobao Live and other platforms that allow you to click a button and go on live and to all of the people that are watching you synchronously and describe it. What’s the providence of this bottle? What is it made of? How rare is it? Let me storytell around what it is. In real time, have people bidding on it, ask questions, and the ability to buy it and pay for it in real time? It’s almost like a QVC, mobile version of QVC with a distributed set of hosts. That was when I technically first invested, they weren’t even doing it yet. I talked to them a lot about doing it. I encouraged them to do it, and they’ve been doing it ever since. That’s a great example of an industry that didn’t exist in the US when I invested. They have grown massively. They’ve announced they did over $3 billion in sales last year. I just did one several months ago in the addiction recovery space, I think a really new approach to helping lots of folks in the US initially, but globally over time, manage their challenges around addiction. There are lots of spaces where there are new experiences to be created. What I get excited about is not only those new experiences in the US that I’m keeping my eyes out for, is taking models that have worked in China or in the US and helping disseminate them to the rest of the world. Finding world-class entrepreneurs in other parts of the globe, helping to either steer them, guide them, or finance them around models that I know work and I know well, and build those equivalent companies in other parts of the world. You see it. You see the Careems of the world taking the Uber model. You see companies in other parts of the world taking DoorDash, GrubHub-type models. That’s what I’ve been doing as well. Obviously, in AI, I see lots of opportunities there. We’ve done some recent investing in terms of the application layer there as well, but consumer and consumer tech marketplaces are where I still spend a lot of my time, and I still think there are lots of opportunities. I’m going to ask one more question of perspective to a potential entrepreneur reaching out to you. I got to talk about potential OPs. You touched on this a little bit. Obviously, helping them in other areas. Obviously, you’ve got a broad background in consumer tech. When someone comes into your portfolio, what else do they get with you and your fund in addition to the capital? I’m going to roll my sleeves. Look, I believe I’m going to help increase the odds for their success. The best entrepreneurs don’t need any investors. That’s the reality, but I believe that as an investor, you can always help, particularly in a couple of different ways. First and foremost, recruiting. I love to recruit. Stitch Fix is a great example. I invested in that company, it was a seed investment. I alone cold-reached out to and recruited the head of all of data science from Netflix, Eric Colson, the COO of Walmart.com. I love when I have conviction in a company, and I believe I’ve backed an entrepreneur who can close great candidates around a theme and around momentum in an opportunity that I think is really big. I love helping to find them great people and helping to recruit those people for them. I think that no matter how great an entrepreneur you are, that helps because of your bandwidth constraint. You are operating your business. You don’t have time to go out and find 25 candidates for this role. That’s super important. I have found that to be super important and effective in all my companies. Look, I think there are other ways that other entrepreneurs want help. Whether it’s fundraising or how to put together a deck. It’s a thought partner around. Go to market or whatever it is. I’ve had a lot of experiences working with companies from the very earliest stages through exit. Through IPOs. I don’t think you’ll find an entrepreneur of mine that I’ve ever worked with who says, “Justin’s unavailable.” When they want my time, they’ve got my time. I work hard to try to be their first call on their best partner. That’s awesome. That’s important, I think, obviously, at the end of the day, entrepreneurs they may need money, but they need good advice too. Probably in more cases than not, we need that first and only. Now I want to pivot. Let’s talk about the LPs and the investors that you have, and what the profile of an investor is, because we’re working with a lot of high net worth individuals who want to get into the venture, but don’t know how to do it. They’re going to try to do individual investments on their own, and unless they’re connected, they’re going to fail miserably. You’ve got advisors who are looking to increase their returns for their client portfolio. Why don’t you share first the profile of some of your current LPs and then what you’re looking for in LPs going forward? My current LP, it’s a pretty wide variety of groups, but I’ve got family offices and high net worth individuals, obviously here in the US, but throughout Europe, I’ve got some in Dubai, I’ve got some in Asia. Pretty wide group, but a number here in the US. Look, my favorite profile and what is led to a typical profile are folks who have an interest in technology in the private markets. It doesn’t mean they know a lot about it, but they have an interest in it and generally want to understand, like how I think about investing and how I think about firm building over time. Look, I agree with you. I think it’s a massive mistake for family offices or individuals to try to do private markets investing on their own. That’s my belief. In this same way, if I have an interest in distressed debt, it’s probably not smart for me to try to go out and start to bid on that and look for those opportunities myself. I should find a world-class firm that has been doing that for a while and has a demonstrated track record of being able to do it effectively, because there are too many smart people trying to do it. If you’re a family officer, high net worth, you’re going to have an adverse selection issue in terms of what you see. You’re not going to see the best stuff. Even if you do see it, you’re not going to win the best stuff. You’re going to have all sorts of issues around pricing and everything else. I found the folks that I think have been the best partners, they have an interest. They want to invest in the fund. They have an interest in hearing about the kinds of stuff I’m investing in. I found it’s great. I can think of two of my LPs in particular, like those who want to learn about it. Over time, they do want to do more direct investing. What they’ve done is like, I spend time with them every month to a month and a half, and like, dive into the portfolio. What’s interesting? Like, do you want to talk to some of these companies? I found that to be effective for a couple of the LPs. I think generally, you’re interested in early-stage tech. You understand why I think it’s as good an asset class as there is, given all the macro tailwinds around it. You want exposure to it. You might want to learn more about it. I think those are the LPs that I’ve found to be the best matches. What else do you want to share? Any final thoughts or anything you want to share to the readers? If there are folks, first of all, any other firm that is watching that is creating something transformational or generational, obviously what I would love to talk to them, and feel free to reach out. Look on the LP or RIA side, if folks want to learn more and they want to understand either dive deeper into my track record and history, or my motivations for starting this firm, or the existing portfolio that we’ve got, or how I think about the world, I’d love it. I love talking about the companies that I backed and my strategy. I’m proud of my track record of the last two decades. I’m not very self-promotional. I don’t do a lot of these things. We’ve been friends for a while, and you’ve been great to me, but I intentionally don’t do a lot of podcasts or blogs or anything like that. I just love backing world-class companies. We love to talk to folks offline if there’s interest, for sure. For those folks who do want to talk offline, how can they get in contact with you? Where should they go? You can find me on LinkedIn, Justin Caldbeck, or you feel free to shoot me an email at JCaldbeck@gmail.com. I think either one of those is a great place. Certainly, probably reference you, Scott, in terms of where you found me. I think that’s a great place to reach out. If you have trouble finding one of those mechanisms, feel free to go through you as well. Justin, thanks for being on the show. I appreciate that. Thank you again. Thank you, Scott. Enjoyed it. — Scott, I Google, which is usually like Gemini. You end up with AI when you get Google things nowadays. I’ve never heard the term monolithic fund before. It made total sense when I looked up the definition of it, but I didn’t really think about what that means, though. How does that monolithic fund? Is it good? Is it bad nowadays? Is it just what you need? It’s interesting because Venture is in a bit of a transition mode. Honestly, I’m glad that our podcast is coming out when it is because venture and these monolithic funds are, in some cases, recent news, are at a crossroads on whether it’s the model, or if it’s the right model, or is it the next model? I think obviously they provide value in the ecosystem, but sometimes it’s easier to turn a sailboat than it is a Titanic. Obviously, you’ve got to be at the right level for that. I thought his perspective on AI was really interesting when we’re talking about that. He’s looking at application layer opportunities across the consumer tech, but focusing more on the consumer side, where I hear from a lot of people focusing more on the industry or business side of AI applications. I thought that was interesting. He’s still interested in that consumer tech marketplace focus for AI. I think obviously, although AI has been around for a while, it’s gotten a lot of press in the last couple of years and even the last few months. Much like the internet, you’re getting that shift from big players and LLM models and the backend to really how it’s going to be applied in the world. Consumers are going to be the biggest consumers of this technology, despite the fact that you’re going to have major data centers, chip manufacturing, and all those other things, how AI can affect consumer behavior, consumer purchases, and their decisions. Their engagement is going to be huge. At the end of the day, I think he is touching on something that is just starting to become prevalent. The average person is sure using a little bit of Gemini or some ChatGPT, but once AI plays into their entire consumer experience, Justin already has those investments in hand. They’ll all be taken care of. I also thought it was really interesting when he started talking about his limited partner approach, his LP approach, and family offices, high net worth individuals, and lending partners. That’s pretty broad. That’s a lot of languages to speak, if you want to think of it that way for him. True. I think because of his experience and background with some of these legendary funds, he understands how to engage with the family office as an investor or an RIA that is representing high net worth individuals or high net worth individuals themselves. I think when you have the experience in the track record, a lot of people are going to come to your door, and he has the background to communicate at all those levels. My favorite thing that he said in the whole interview was that the best entrepreneurs don’t need any investors. I agree. That’s a really interesting thing. Honestly, I’m so glad he said that. I was in complete agreement because the reality is 99.8% of founders won’t get venture capital and are probably better off not getting venture capital. There are countless stories about companies grew tremendously with no outside capital. It’s even happening now. The trend now is to do what’s called a C scaling. Basically, they just take a small amount of money to get started because raising money is such a difficult proposition. I think build a company and the business and the income and revenue will find it. I agree. I’m all about that. We used to call it bootstrapping, but the reality is this. It creates a lot more innovation at the end of the day because you have to figure out how to make things work with what you’ve got. That makes them pretty resilient entrepreneurs. When they do go to the big arounds later, they’re ready for it. I know I was so impressed with Justin Caldbeck, DGV is really fascinating to me. I cannot wait for the next ones you keep bringing up here. You’ve got great connections, Scott. I don’t know how you do it, but you’ve been traveling all over the place. Tell us a little bit about the kinds of events you’ve been doing lately. We’re heading to Austin, Texas, next week. We’re taking one of our portfolio companies on a road show to meet with investors around the country. We’ll be in Austin, Miami, and California. We’re launching a new series of events called Innovators and Investors, where they’re not necessarily pitch events. They’re just high-profile opportunities for people to connect. We didn’t want to Tampa Bay, my hometown here, and taking that on the road, and pretty excited about it. You and I are going to see each other soon because you’re going to be out in California. Coming to California. At an Expert DOJO event in Santa Monica. We will see each other live in person there, too. You all have to check out the website EmergingManagersPodcast.com and make sure, because we’ve always got links to the latest events and the latest things going on for VC Fast Pitch and for Black Dog Venture Partners.
Justin Caldbeck is a seasoned venture capitalist with a remarkable track record of early investments in some of the most iconic tech companies of our time, including LinkedIn, Stitch Fix, Grubhub, and Snapchat.
Justin Caldbeck of DGV
Delving Into The Thesis Of DGV
Why Choose DGV
Looking Forward With Confidence
Mike Smith, the head of online for Sephora, Julie Bornstein, the head of engineering for Opower, and multiple data scientists and engineers. With Whatnot? I had a similar run where I recruited a number of their senior execs. I am right now for one of my security companies. I’ve just made multiple intros to the head of marketing and the head of sales candidates for them.How DGV Chooses its LPs and Investors
Building Connections With World-Class Companies
Episode Wrap-Up And Closing Words
What I thought was interesting about this idea is that the monolithic funds that their focus is on the returns and the capital raising side of things, when you don’t have to worry about that, and your investment fund is worrying about that for you. That makes it a little easier, honestly, to concentrate on making sure that you’re increasing your profits and you’re doing the things that are necessary to grow the business to the stage. I do think, from a founder’s perspective, that that’s a great partnership for the right level company.Important Links